Will Falconer, DVM Moderator
Hi nancy,
I'm speaking to Rebecca's unique situation. Everyone's is somewhat different. Obviously, a dog living in Gnome or in Hawaii or New Zealand (the latter two being known rabies free) would not need one.
As you'll read in the thread, she lives in a different world. I think I spelled it out pretty clearly, now that I've just reread it after a year.
You have to weigh risks vs benefits where you live and deciding how you and your dog will live in the world. Not an open and shut or "one size fits all" situation, as I hope you can appreciate.